Tuesday, November 12, 2013

Ryan McDonough and the NBA Version of Moneyball



          Ryan McDonough is the new General Manager of the Phoenix Suns, a team that desperately needs to rebuild after jettisoning their franchise point guard to the Los Angeles Lakers last summer and they have yet to forge a new team identity.  It used to be the run and gun Suns of the west, led by former back to back MVP Steve Nash.  With the twilight of his career always imminent due to severe back concerns, for years the Suns tried to surround Nash with enough talent to compete for a championship, but ill-fated pairings with Shaquille O’Neal and Amarè Stoudemire netted them zero championships and since Nash traded, there has not been any visible plan to build a competitive team in Phoenix.

            After Nash left, the Suns quickly signed promising young point guard Goran Dragic, which would have been a great move, had they not kicked him to the curb the year before, trading him to Houston at the trading deadline.  Then, the Suns went after complementary wing players from Minnesota, Michael Beasley and Wesley Johnson.  One year later and only Dragic remains on the roster, yet they are still paying Beasley not to play for them.  Next up, the Suns then acquire coveted point guard Eric Bledsoe from the Clippers in a deal where they ship out Jared Dudley.  Bledsoe is certainly a promising young player, even if there are questions about his ability to run a team full time, but they already have Dragic at that position, so the Suns will be asking them to share the ball and play together, which will be feast or famine, but certainly not anywhere in between.  The main issue with the Bledsoe trade is that they did not sign him to an extension, so at the end of the season he will be a restricted free agent and someone will likely offer him a front or back loaded offer sheet that the Suns could match, but it would mess up their cap space.  It would be hard to imagine that Bledsoe would have turned down a contract extension in the $8-11 million per year offer, which might seem a bit high now, but this will seem very reasonable when he is on the open market this summer.

            So, without any expectations for this year’s team, McDonough is content to acquire attractive young pieces to see who he can grab in the 2014 draft and the players currently on the roster who will be the best complimentary player to the draftees will be retained.  So far Ryan has been extremely successful in the pursuit of highly coveted 2014 draft picks, potentially owning four top 15 picks in the draft that they could package together to make a real splash by potentially being able to get two top 5 picks.  There could be as many as eight potential all stars in this draft class, and if the Suns were able to get an Andrew Wiggins or a Jabari Parker, they have the roster flexibility to build around these players right away, and also being bad enough that player’s rookie year to also get a high lottery pick in the 2015 draft.  This has been the model that smaller market franchises have used since they saw what Sam Presti was able to do in Oklahoma City after being tied to a more conservative budget after the franchise relocated from the larger market of Seattle.  McDonough’s legacy is going to be always linked to the players he selects in the draft next year, and he should be in good position to do so, having worked his way up from video coordinator to assistant GM with the Boston Celtics in 2010 at the impressive age of 30.  

            Danny Ainge rebuilt the Celtics in a traditional way in 2007, acquiring a couple veterans for young players and draft picks.  This is going to be the first time that Ainge is going to have to build through the draft, as this time he was the one who traded the veteran talent for young players and a plethora of draft picks.  Just because this is the first time that Ainge has been tasked with this, does not mean that he has not been prepared for this, with rumors circulating of trades of members of the big three during the trade deadline in 2011, when Ray Allen was actively shopped with the Celtics underperforming during the first half of the season.  There have been countless other rumors of failed Pierce and Garnett trades as well, with Ainge ultra-aware of the need to get value for his veterans before while also ensuring that they would get one last shot to compete for a championship.  With all these scenarios being tossed around in the front office in Boston, it’s no surprise that new age GM Daryl Morey came from Boston as well and has had success without rebuilding through many creative trades and draft picks.  McDonough is taking the surest bet right now, taking over a team that already had no hope of contending, he has acquired four first round draft picks in next year’s draft, while maintaining salary cap flexibility as well.

            With a family background in sports, Ryan is no stranger to the business as well as the many ideas floated around by sportswriters, particularly his father’s.  Ryan’s father was famed Boston Globe columnist Wil McDonough, and his brother Sean McDonough is a household voice, if not a household name, who currently broadcasts college football, and was the formed voice of the Boston Red Sox.  Ryan’s other brother, Terry, works in the NFL in player personnel decisions, covering almost all of the major sports within the McDonough family.  Ryan himself majored in Journalism and Mass Communication at the University of North Carolina, no doubt intending to follow in his father’s footsteps before accepting a position with the Celtics’ front office.  With Morey and McDonough coming out of the front office, Danny Ainge has become the NBA version of Billy Beane, teaching his workers the new era of working the front office in the league, acquiring young talent with draft picks to develop or include in future blockbuster trades.  This is the new model of the league, and while Ainge started the trend, Sam Presti is looked to as the best example due to the success he had in the front office with the Thunder, drafting Kevin Durant, Russell Westbrook and James Harden, who made up three out of the best five players in the entire league.  Presti needs to be given credit where it’s due, and he does not get any for taking Durant, who was a no brainer after the Blazers selected Greg Oden first overall.  Presti’s genius comes with the Westbrook drafting, who people said that they took him way too high and he would not be able to convert from shooting guard to playing point guard in the league.  James Harden was a heralded player at Arizona State, but no one ever really thought he would turn into the player he has become today on the Rockets, first being able to step out of the shadows into a leading man role, and finding a lot of success. With the Thunder as the new model for rebuilding teams to follow, it is increasingly harder to try and build this way, due to the nature of the new collective bargaining agreement.  The new CBA puts a cap on the limit of draft pick salaries, in the same way the CBA in the NFL was revised a couple years ago.  This makes draft picks much more attractive to all the teams with the restrictive nature of the new salary cap, which penalizes teams over the cap with sever luxury tax penalties.  With a first round draft pick, the player is locked up on rookie scale wages for a solid four years, with the potential to sign and extension or issue a qualifying offer at that time, making the player a restricted free agent, meaning the team he is on has a chance to match any offer by another team.  Also new in the CBA are monetary incentives to stay with the current team, who can offer another year and millions more dollars to their hometown star than another team could in free agency.  This will not always work, as in the case of Dwight Howard this summer, but the majority of the time, it should be enough to sweeten the pot for all but the top tier superstars who can potentially make up for the lost guaranteed salary in endorsement opportunities in larger markets.   Bottom line is, it is harder than ever to amass draft picks, and McDonough has succeeded in the best draft class in a decade.

            The most valuable draft pick the Suns have will most likely be their own, where they have a good chance to compete with the worst teams in the league for the most ping pong balls in the tank for Wiggins.  They also have a top 12 pick from Washington in the Marcin Gortat trade, a top 13 protected pick from Minnesota from the Robin Lopez trade a couple years ago, and a lottery protected pick from the Pacers.  Most likely scenario, they have the pick from Washington and the Pacers, which is looking like it will be toward the end of the first round.  If they have luck with their own pick, they can select whichever player is highest on their board, see how the rest of the roster will mesh, and plug holes with the other picks, or try and make a splash and trade the picks to select again in the top five or ten, depending on how the lottery plays out.  In the NBA, potential is valued perhaps more than any other league, and although Ryan McDonough is showing great potential, his legacy in Phoenix rests on the bounces of ping pong balls to determine the most important player they draft in 2014, and what direction this franchise is going to take in the foreseeable future.

No comments:

Post a Comment